How to Bounce Back from a Poor Hiring Decision in Your Plastics Manufacturing Firm

There’s one key factor that differentiates successful plastics manufacturing firms from the rest. And it’s the quality of talent they hire. The talent who comprise your team can make or break your operations. They can propel your firm to new heights, or they can be a source of unnecessary cost and stress. A poor hiring decision, unfortunately, falls into the latter category.

Even the best of firms make poor hiring decisions at times. And what matters most is how you react, learn, and bounce back from these scenarios – turning a bad hiring experience into an opportunity for growth and improvement.

In this blog, we’ll explore the impacts of a poor hiring decision, how to mitigate them and most importantly, how you can recover and refine your hiring practices moving forward.

The Impact of a Bad Hire

A poor hiring decision can have far-reaching impacts on a plastics manufacturing firm, both in financial and non-financial terms.

Financial Implications

From the recruitment process to onboarding and training, every stage in the hiring process translates to significant investment. According to the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM), the cost of a bad hire can be up to five times that individual’s annual salary when you factor in both the direct and indirect costs. These costs include not only the hiring and training expenses but also severance pay and potential legal fees if the separation becomes complicated.

Moreover, there are potential productivity losses to be considered. A bad hire could lead to project delays, missed deadlines, compromised product quality, or customer dissatisfaction – all of which can have significant monetary implications.

Non-Financial Impacts

Beyond the monetary perspective, several less tangible yet critical factors can be affected by a poor hire. A subpar performer or a poor culture fit can negatively impact team morale – in fact, about 95% of respondents in a survey from Robert Half believed that a poor hiring decision at least somewhat have caused this.

Additionally, a bad hire can strain company resources, take up management’s valuable time, and cause overall team productivity to decline. There is also the risk of tarnishing the company’s reputation, as word travels fast in the industry.

5 Signs You’ve Made a Bad Hire

Identifying a bad hire early on can save your organization a lot of time, money, and headache. But what are the signs that you’ve made a poor hiring decision? Pay attention to these key indicators:

  • Consistent underperformance: A clear sign of a problematic hire is a consistent inability to meet performance benchmarks. In plastics manufacturing, this might manifest as a machine operator who often mishandles equipment or doesn’t keep up with production timelines, thereby impacting productivity and work schedules.
  • Persistent negative attitude: An employee who regularly displays an unconstructive attitude – exhibiting disinterest in their tasks, showing indifference towards team goals, or engaging in conflicts with colleagues – can spoil the workplace environment. This negative behavior can severely hamper team collaboration and efficiency, particularly crucial in a teamwork-intensive sector like plastics manufacturing.
  • Failure to integrate with the team: Effective cooperation is intrinsic to the smooth operation of manufacturing processes. If a new recruit consistently struggles to mesh with the existing team, causing strife or communication breakdowns, it suggests a misalignment between the hire and the team dynamics.
  • Frequent unplanned absences: Regular tardiness or unexplained absences not only disrupt the well-oiled machinery of production schedules but may also point towards a lack of commitment or interest in the job. This erratic attendance can lower overall team morale when others must compensate for the unexpected workload.
  • Reliance on constant supervision: While initial guidance is a given for any new hire, an employee requiring relentless supervision or one who doesn’t learn from repeated instructions represents a drain on managerial resources. This continuous need for oversight may demonstrate their unsuitability for a fast-moving, self-starter environment typical of plastics manufacturing.

Spotting these signs early can help you take prompt corrective action, whether it’s additional training, coaching, reshuffling roles, or even termination.

How to Recover from a Poor Hiring Decision

Recognizing a poor hiring decision is only an initial step. The next question is, how do you bounce back from it? Here are the steps you should take:

Step 1. Conduct comprehensive performance review

Begin with a thorough review of the employee’s work. Are they consistently making operational errors? Perhaps they’re unable to keep up with the production pace? Or maybe they’re causing friction within the team? Using quantifiable information can help provide a clear picture and establish whether the employee is meeting their job requirements.

Step 2. Provide constructive feedback and support

Open and effective communication lines are key. Have a candid conversation with the employee. Let them know where they’re falling short and provide specific examples. Are they perpetually late on their deliverables? Are they struggling with operating specific machinery? Offer them resources or training to help improve their performance.

Step 3. Create a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP)

If the issues persist, it may be worth putting together a PIP. This plan should detail concrete performance goals, provide a timeline for achieving them, and outline any strategies or support you’ll offer. This could be in the form of additional training sessions or closer one-to-one supervision.

Step 4. Consider role adjustment
Sometimes, the issue might not be the person but the role they’re in. If someone is struggling on the production line, they might be better suited to a quality inspection role. It’s worth considering whether there might be a better fit for them within your organization.

Step 5. Terminate if necessary

If you’ve exhausted all options and there’s still no improvement, it might be time to make the tough decision to let the employee go. While this is never an easy step, it’s often better for both parties in the long run – relieving the team of any unnecessary stress and allowing the employee to find a role better suited to their abilities elsewhere.

Step 6. Review the hiring process

Once the immediate situation is handled, review your hiring process. Identify where you went wrong and implement improvements to avoid repeating the same mistake.

Remember, the goal is to turn a challenging situation into a learning experience that strengthens your company’s future hiring decisions.

Learning from the Experience

Although recruiting a poor candidate might be a difficult experience, it also presents an opportunity for learning and refining your hiring process. Here’s how you can transform a poor hiring decision into a beneficial learning experience:

  1. Reviewing the recruitment process: A thorough audit of your recruitment process can help identify any weak points or blind spots that may have led to the poor hiring decision. Was the job description clear and accurate? Were the right questions asked in the interview? Were there any missed red flags in the background checks?
  2. Improving interview techniques: Reflect on your interview process. Take into account whether adding behavioral-style interviews, practical tests, or group interview dynamics can provide more insight into the candidate’s actual skills and cultural fit.
  3. Enhancing onboarding practices: Look into your onboarding practices. Provide clear expectations from the beginning and establish a robust training program to set up your new hires for success.
  4. Evaluating your culture fit assessment: Assess how you judge ‘culture fit.’ It’s crucial to ensure that the process is unbiased and inclusive, focusing on shared values instead of superficial commonalities.
  5. Learning to trust your instincts: While data-driven decisions are necessary, it’s also essential to trust your instincts. If something feels off about a candidate, it’s worth digging a little deeper.

The key is to take a proactive approach to learn from your mistakes and consistently improve your hiring practices – turning a negative experience into a positive outcome.

Implementing Improved Hiring Practices

Recovering from a poor hiring decision requires more than just recognition of the problem. Here’s how you can strategically revamp your hiring practices into a more refined, efficient, and effective system:

Leveraging Technology

The use of technology has revolutionized the hiring process. The right tech tools can enhance the efficiency, speed, and quality of your recruitment process:

  • Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS): ATSs help keep track of candidates throughout the hiring process. They organize and store candidate information, automate communication, and streamline scheduling, making the recruitment process efficient and hassle-free. In addition, ATSs can help avoid any potential bias, as they screen resumes based on specific criteria, ensuring a fair selection process.
  • AI-Powered skill tests: These tools provide an objective measure of a candidate’s skills and competencies, removing human error or bias from the evaluation process. For example, in plastics manufacturing, AI could evaluate candidates’ problem-solving skills through simulations, predict their ability to perform under pressure, or even their ability to adapt to new technologies.
  • Video interviewing platforms: Video interviews have become a mainstay in the modern hiring process. They enable you to interview candidates from anywhere in the world, widening your talent pool. Recorded interviews can also be reviewed later, allowing for more thorough analysis and reducing the chance of a hasty decision.


Refining Job Descriptions

Job descriptions play a pivotal role in the recruitment process. They form the first point of contact between your company and potential candidates, shaping their first impression of the role and the organization. Here’s how you can refine your job descriptions:

  • Clarity and precision: Ensure that duties, responsibilities, and key performance indicators are clearly articulated. This helps candidates understand their potential role and whether they meet the necessary qualifications. Avoid jargon or vague terms that could lead to misunderstandings.
  • Skills, certifications, and experience: Be crystal clear about the specific skills, qualifications, and experience required for the job. This helps to filter out under- or overqualified candidates. For example, in the plastics manufacturing industry, specify the machinery or software a candidate needs to be proficient with.
  • Company culture: Job descriptions should portray your company culture and values accurately. This gives candidates an insight into the work environment, helping them determine whether they’d be a cultural fit.
  • Inviting format: Structure the job description in an easy-to-read, inviting format. Use bullet points, headings, and short paragraphs to make the content digestible and attractive to prospective applicants.


Data-Driven Hiring

In today’s world, people often say that data is king – and hiring is no exception. Utilizing data in your recruitment process can lead to more accurate, predictable, and fair hiring decisions:

  • Performance data analysis: Look at your top performing employees. What common skills, traits, or backgrounds do they have? By analyzing this data, you can identify patterns or competencies that lead to success in your firm, guiding your selection of future candidates.
  • Industry benchmarking: Gathering data about industry standards, such as average salary ranges, key skills, and experience levels, can ensure your expectations align with the market. This can enhance your job descriptions and ensure your offers are competitive.
  • Hiring metrics: Track your hiring process metrics, such as time-to-fill, sourcing channel efficiency, or interview-to-offer ratio. These can provide insights into where your process excels or where it needs improvement.
  • Candidate experience feedback: Collect feedback from candidates about their experience during the recruitment process. Their insights can help improve your practices, making your firm more attractive to top talent.


Cultural Fit Assessment

Finding the right skills is crucial, but true success often comes when an employee aligns well with the company culture. Here’s how to effectively assess cultural fit:

  • Value-based interview questions: Craft interview questions that can gauge a candidate’s personal values and see if they align with your company culture. For instance, if your company values teamwork, you might ask about a time when they contributed to a team’s success.
  • Behavioral assessment: Behavioral assessments can predict how a candidate will act in certain job-related situations. These can help you understand if a candidate’s working style will fit well within your team.
  • Social interactions: While formal interviews can provide many insights, informal settings can often reveal more about a potential hire’s true personality. Observe the candidate’s interaction with potential co-workers, or even how they treat the receptionist.
  • Reference checks: Conduct reference checks to get a more holistic understanding of the candidate. Previous employers or colleagues can provide insights into the candidate’s work ethic, interpersonal skills, and adaptability.

Remember, skills can be taught, but values and attitudes are ingrained. Assessing cultural fit can help ensure a harmonious and productive work environment.


Working with Plastic Executive Recruiters

Partnering with a specialized recruitment agency like Plastic Executive Recruiters can be a game-changer for your hiring process:

  • Industry expertise: As specialists in plastics manufacturing recruitment, we possess a deep understanding of the industry nuances. We can provide valuable insights to guide your hiring decisions, reducing the chances of a poor hire.
  • Wide talent network: Our extensive network enables us to reach a broad pool of qualified candidates, including those who may not be actively seeking a new job but could be enticed by the right opportunity.
  • Time and cost efficiency: With our experienced team handling your recruitment process, you’ll save significant time and resources that can be directed towards other strategic aspects of your business.
  • Post-hire support: Our involvement doesn’t end when a candidate is hired. We provide continued support to ensure a smooth transition and successful integration into your team.

Bouncing back from a poor hiring decision doesn’t have to be a solo battle. Partnering with Plastic Executive Recruiters can streamline your recruitment process and help you avoid future hiring pitfalls. Reach out to us today and together, let’s learn, grow, and make better hiring decisions.

Ed Keil

Got QUEstions?

Ed Keil, "The Plastics Recruiter"

No problem! Click on the button to the right to schedule
your call with Ed Keil, "The Plastics Recruiter" 

Presets Color